Best Crumbl cookie flavors

Crumbl does not publish a best-of list. These 30 are the flavors with the most reviews on the official profiles we copied, which is a popularity count, not our tasting notes.

What is the best Crumbl cookie of all time?

By review count in our copy of the profiles, Milk Chocolate Chip Cookie leads with 791,996 reviews at 4.59 stars. That is Crumbl's number.

30 Crumbl flavors with the most reviews on profiles we copied
RankFlavorReviewsStarsCaloriesWeeks in our archive
1Milk Chocolate Chip Cookie791,9964.596600
2Brownie Batter Cookie327,2604.586901
3Pink Sugar Cookie260,7474.487600
4Pink Velvet Cake Cookie212,9384.486900
5Churro Cookie203,4264.528002
6Snickerdoodle Cookie181,9504.535901
7Molten Lava Cookie168,7024.56500
8Tres Leches Cake166,1894.617901
9Birthday Cake Cookie ft. OREO®160,7284.437802
10Confetti Cake Cookie160,3274.457800
11Brookie Cookie158,3934.476300
12Galaxy Brownie Cookie155,2854.386400
13Caramel Shortbread Cookie ft. TWIX®154,2554.286902
14Cereal Milk Cookie ft. Fruity PEBBLES™141,3144.186801
15Peanut Butter Cup Cookie ft. REESE'S122,4544.477502
16Cornbread Cookie122,3104.328401
17Snickerdoodle Cupcake Cookie121,2314.567902
18Cinnamon Roll Cookie113,0914.477501
19Banana Bread Cookie106,5284.376601
20Caramel Apple Cookie104,8964.477902
21Strawberry Ice Cream Bar Cookie101,8814.429001
22Raspberry Butter Cake Cookie98,1134.376800
23Raspberry Cheesecake85,7634.578101
24Biscoff® Ice Cream Cookie82,5734.477501
25Dubai-Style Chocolate Cookie82,1914.659900
26Ultimate Peanut Butter Cookie78,4244.397201
27Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Cookie77,6384.134601
28Strawberry Shortcake76,0604.598001
29Lemon Bar Cookie73,8394.327001
30Lemon Glaze Cookie72,3104.325700

What you can buy right now is the weekly menu, not this ranking.

What is the best Crumbl cookie?

There is no official ranking. This page lists flavors people keep searching, then this week's baked board so you can buy what is actually in stores.

How is Crumbl different from other cookie shops?

Crumbl rotates the weekly desserts and keeps a few classics, including Chocolate Chip and Pink Sugar. The week of Nov 16 - 22, 2026 has 6 rotating desserts and 3 classics.