Crumbl Banana Cream Pie Cookie

What the Banana Cream Pie Cookie is

Crumbl describes it as “Silky vanilla pudding layered with fresh banana slices and vanilla wafers over a buttery baked pie crust.”

Crumbl customers rate it 4.27 out of 5 across 9,405 ratings on its official profile.

Banana Cream Pie Cookie calories and nutrition

Crumbl lists 540 calories per serving, about 27% of a 2,000-calorie day, with 45 g of sugar and 11 g of saturated fat (55% of the Daily Value).

Allergens

Crumbl’s profile lists Milk, Egg, Wheat, Soy. Crumbl bakes in an open kitchen that also uses peanuts and tree nuts, so check the full allergen view in the app if an allergy is severe.

When the Banana Cream Pie Cookie was on the menu

• Sep 13 - 19, 2026

Our archive runs from June 2026 and has a gap between mid-July and early September, so an appearance in that window would not show here.

Price

We track a typical U.S. price of $5.99. Box prices and the price per cookie are on the price guide, and how to keep leftovers is on the storage guide.

Similar Crumbl desserts

• Oatmeal Creme Pie Cookie: Two oatmeal cookies sandwiching a layer of marshmallow cream cheese frosting. 530 cal per serving.
• Pumpkin Pie Cookie: A buttery pie crust cookie with spiced pumpkin pie filling finished with a dollop of fluffy whipped cream and a dash of cinnamon. 710 cal per serving.
• Biscoff® Pie: A Biscoff®–infused cream cheese pie filling served on a crunchy Biscoff® crust, finished with a pool of smooth Biscoff® spread, dollops of fresh whipped cream, and a crunchy Biscoff® cookie. 1100 cal per serving.

Source: description, nutrition, allergens, and rating copied from Crumbl’s Banana Cream Pie Cookie profile on Oct 21, 2026. Bakeries can vary, so the Crumbl app panel for your store is the final word.

Banana Cream Pie Cookie FAQs